I’ll give you Dirk’s stats and accomplishments compared to another NBA player and you tell me who’s better:
Dirk:
1x Champion 1x MVP 1x FMVP 14x All-Star 10x All-NBA 1st/2nd 20.7 PPG (playoffs 25.3 PPG) 7.5 RPG (playoffs 10.0 RPG) 2.4 APG (playoffs 2.5 APG) led a team to a championship win as underdog
Player B:
1x Champion 1x FMVP 1x Scoring champ 12x All-Star 10x All-NBA / ABA 1st/2nd 24.8 PPG (playoffs 27.3 PPG) 6.7 RPG (playoffs 6.4 RPG) 4.9 APG (playoffs 4.3 APG) led a team to a championship win as underdog
ok so Dirk has one MVP and 2 all-star selections over Player B but Player B has the edge in scoring right? At the very least, you would say that Dirk and Player B are roughly in the same tier when it comes to ranking.
Have you heard of Player B? It’s Rick Barry.
How often have you heard Rick Barry’s name mentioned in the top 25 and how often have you heard Dirk’s name mentioned in the top 25? That pretty much answers the question here. Rick Barry is far more underrated than Dirk is.
You have three all time small forwards playing around the same era. Baylor was the earliest but his career overlaps a bit with the other two.
Let’s go category by category as all three of these players can do a bit of everything on the court:
Scoring – this one is tough – it’s either Baylor or Barry both of them were monster scorers in their prime. Baylor has the third highest PPG all time at 27.4 PPG and peaked at 38 PPG in 1962. Barry’s overall career PPG is lower at 25 PPG but peaks almost as high at 36 PPG in 1967. Baylor’s career high is 71 PTS and STILL holds the record for most points in a Finals at 61 PTS. Barry though, holds the highest Finals scoring average of all time at 36 PPG – and averaged 41 PPG vs Wilt’s 76ers in the 1967 Finals. It’s super close between Baylor and Barry and you could pick either one and get one of the best scoring forwards of all time.
Rebounding – definitely Baylor. Baylor averaged 13.5 RPG as a 6′5 forward. That’s pretty insane and shows how athletic he was. He peaked at 18 RPG in 1962. While Barry was a very good rebounder in his early years before his knee injuries, he never really matched Baylor and Havlicek is a fine rebounder for his position too but ranks third here.
Passing – very close between Barry and Havlicek. Both Barry and Havlicek could be considered prototype point forwards. Barry had a few seasons averaging 6+ APG and Havlicek had a few seasons averaging 7+ APG. At their peaks, Havlicek *might* have the slight edge here but Barry was consistently a great passer after his knee injuries forced him to be more of a perimeter player. Super close and both had great competing teams in the 1970s. You could pick either one and get one of the best passing forwards ever. Baylor was also a pretty decent passer, but he was a level below these two.
Defense – definitely Havlicek. Havlicek was a 8x All-Defensive player. “Havlicek steals the ball!’ is ingrained in the minds of many old school basketball fans. Havlicek was similar to Pippen in his day, he was a very smart help defender and great at perimeter defense. Barry and Baylor weren’t known for their defense.
Awards – Baylor doesn’t have a championship. Barry has one championship and Finals MVP. Havlicek has 8 championships and a Finals MVP. I think it’s pretty clear here that Havlicek has the advantage when it comes to awards. Havlicek was 8–0 in the Finals. In 3 of his championships, he was a top 2 player on the team. Fun fact is if Jerry West had not gotten the Finals MVP in 1969 and the FMVP went to a player on the winning team instead – it would have gone to Havlicek as Russell although still very valuable was on the decline in his last season. Havlicek was far and away the best offensive player on the Celtics that season.
So overall I’ll have to rank them as follows – Havlicek (top 20 player, great passer, great defender, 8 rings), Barry (top 25 player, great scorer, great passer), Baylor (top 25 player, great scorer, great rebounder) – in that order.
Rick Barry and Kobe actually share a lot of crazy similarities, from their arrogance/hyper competitiveness to disdainful treatment of their teammates to them both giving up on their team in a Game 7, BOTH against the Suns. Both were fierce competitors on the court who’s perfectionism irritated teammates and opponents alike. The difference is – Kobe is one of the most beloved athletes of all time and Barry is one of the most hated. Why is that?
Here’s what I can think of:
-Rick Barry was viewed as an asshole to people both on and off the court. Kobe was an asshole to people only on the court.
-Rick Barry was not a good father by many accounts. Kobe is recognized as a great father.
-Rick Barry gave up on his team in a Game 7 because his teammates didn’t back him up in a fight, while Kobe gave up on his team in a Game 7 because he wanted to spite his coach (Phil Jackson). Both are black stains on each players resume, but I think Kobe’s is a bit more inexcusable.
-Rick Barry had mamba mentality at a time when being a great teammate was paramount. He was most definitely robbed of an MVP since MVPs were voted on by players back then. Jordan made having ultra-competitive asshole energy cool, and Kobe followed Jordan in having the same kind of attitude. Had Rick Barry played in the modern nba, he’d be viewed quite differently – as a killer competitor rather than a prick.
-Kobe and Jordan were both much more athletic, more marketable and had more championships. This made their arrogant attitude a bit more easier to tolerate. Kind of like how Steve Jobs was an asshole but because he accomplished so much, people ended up still idolizing him. Poor Rick Barry only had one championship to his credit, and thus made his arrogance harder to justify. Despite being an all time great player, Barry isn’t nearly ranked as high as Kobe and Jordan usually are.
-Rick Barry was also seen as a racist, probably stemming from the one incident with Bill Russell that he had while they were commentating together on a match in the 1980s. He also made fun of Southern people’s accents when he refused to play for the Virginia Squires. Whether Barry was actually a racist or his lack of a social filter always speaking what’s on his mind, I’m not sure.
-Kobe also had that infamous rape trial, but seems to be totally forgiven and swept under the rug now. Barry does not get forgiven for any of his past behavior in contrast.
Now keep in mind, I’m a Rick Barry fan and I’ve watched a lot of his interviews and podcasts online, and never in any one of them have I ever seen him act like an asshole or a prick. He’s always given sound basketball analysis and advice and championed the play of his children, so I’m not sure where all the hate for Barry comes from – is it from people hearing about his past incidents or whether he’s just misunderstood. Like Barry himself says ‘I don’t know why so many people get this impression about me when they’ve never even met me!’
In any case, it seems like there is an unfortunate double standard in how people view Rick Barry and Kobe/Jordan despite their similar arrogant/competitive attitudes. Whether or not Barry deserves the hate – I’m not sure, but personally I think he’s a bit misunderstood, and probably doesn’t deserve to be hated the way he is, at least not while Kobe is praised for the way he is. One thing is for certain which is that Barry seems to have burned a lot of bridges in a way that Kobe/Jordan did not.
Below you can see all the evidence of Kobe being an asshole that he is either excused for or praised for:
Why is Rick Barry seemingly so forgotten by modern NBA fans and analysts?
Whenever a list of the top SFs all time get mentioned, inevitably there’s Lebron and Bird, Dr J, KD and Pippen get mentioned, and sometimes Elgin Baylor, James Worthy, Dominique Wilkins and even Paul Pierce get thrown in.
..but what about Rick Barry?
For people who don’t know how much of a statistical beast Rick was, his playoff stats were monstrous:
1967 playoffs – 34.7 PPG / 7.5 RPG / 3.9 APG
1970 playoffs – 40.1 PPG / 10.0 RPG / 3.3 APG
1971 playoffs – 33.7 PPG / 11.7 RPG / 4.0 APG
1972 playoffs – 30.8 PPG / 6.5 RPG / 3.8 APG
1975 playoffs – 28.2 PPG / 5.5 RPG / 6.1 APG
1976 playoffs – 24.0 PPG / 6.5 RPG / 6.5 APG
1977 playoffs – 28.4 PPG / 5.9 RPG / 4.7 APG
He’s one of only 4 players to ever win a ring without another all star on his team (the others are Ben Wallace, Hakeem Olajuwon and Dirk Nowitzki)
He’s the only player to ever lead the NCAA, ABA AND NBA in scoring
He was the first SF that you could call a ‘point forward’ due to his passing ability
He had the highest FT% in history at the time he retired
“He was Larry Bird before Larry Bird” is what many fans who watched him play said about him
He has the highest scoring Finals Average of all time at 36 PPG, even beating out Michael Jordan’s 33 PPG
He has over 25k career points if you include his ABA stats
(which the NBA should and is baffling that they don’t because you know, they merged so ABA history should be part of NBA history)
He had “mamba mentality” way before Jordan/Kobe made it popular; He would never shy away from shooting a shot, he was psychologically competitive and he was tough on his teammates. The problem was, back in the 1970s this type of mentality was widely disliked and hence he was probably robbed of a few MVPs (which were voted on by players back then). Now, ironically we praise players with this kind of mentality.
Head to Head matchups versus other SF greats of the time:
Rick Barry vs Elgin Baylor
Barry – 28.2 / 9.8 / 3.1 / 44% FG%
Baylor – 19.4 / 9.5 / 2.4 / 42% FG%
Rick Barry vs Connie Hawkins
Barry – 23.4 / 6.9 / 5.7 / 45% FG%
Hawkins – 15.0 / 7.1 / 4.7 / 50% FG%
Rick Barry vs Billy Cunningham
Barry – 29.5 / 7.4 / 3.2 / 44% FG%
Cunningham – 16.5 / 9.6 / 3.5 / 44% FG%
Rick Barry vs Gus Johnson
Barry – 32.1 / cant find other stats on their h2h matchups
Gus – 19.4 / cant find other stats on their h2h matchups
Rick Barry vs Roger Brown
Barry – 28.5 / cant find other stats on their h2h matchups Brown – 21.4 / cant find other stats on their h2h matchups
Rick Barry vs Julius Erving
Barry – 24.7 / cant find other stats on their h2h matchups
Dr J – 26.6 / cant find other stats on their h2h matchups
Rick Barry vs John Havlicek
Barry – 28.1 / 8.4 / cant find other stats on their h2h matchups Hondo – 22 / 5.7 / cant find other stats on their h2h matchups
Rick Barry vs Chet Walker
Barry – 27.2 / 8.1 / 3.7 / 45% FG%
Chet – 20.1 / 6.5 / 2.8 / 49% FG%
So as you can see, Barry basically destroyed every other SF of his era – the only exception being Dr J (who was younger than Barry)
How could a player so dominant at his position be routinely left out in conversations? SLAM magazine left him out of their all time SF mount rushmore candidates – but inexplicably put Carmelo Anthony and Paul Pierce there. ESPN left him out of their all time Warriors starting lineup, instead putting in Draymond Green over him. TNT’s 2011 All-Star Fantasy Draft where 6 analysts drafted 10 players each – Barry was not picked.
It’s inexplicable to me that Rick Barry is mostly forgotten and even if he is remembered, mostly remembered for his granny style free throw shot and him being a racist commentator. When I went to watch the Warriors games, I was the only one wearing a Rick Barry jersey. Sometimes I even saw Mullin jerseys – but never Barry jerseys (or Thurmond jerseys for that matter). And that’s kind of sad because not only should his dominance as a player be remembered, but he’s one of the few players back then who would thrive in today’s game with his ultra competitiveness, his point forward skills, his complete game (post, interior, perimeter) and his long range shooting.
Thoughts? I think he’s one of my top 2 most underrated players of all time along with Artis Gilmore.
Another basketball post! yay! In this post I want to talk about just how underrated ABA players.
Edit: I made a video about the top 10 underrated players here:
httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Z9tVTAuHHA
For those of you who don’t know, the American Basketball Association or ABA, was founded as an alternative league to the NBA and at that time alot of players who felt that the NBA wasn’t paying them enough or too traditional took to the ABA which had a lot of modern rules like the 3 point range, a colored ball, etc
However, the ABA eventually merged with the NBA in 1976, but the NBA refuses to merge ABA player’s career records with the NBA, which is a disservice to former ABA players who later went to the NBA. As a result, several former great ABA players are underrated by the public both because ABA games were not readily televised back in the day, and because their career totals are not fully accounted for in the NBA.
Some of these great players include:
1. Mel Daniels
Mel Daniels
Has anyone ever heard of Mel Daniels? Well before I looked him up I haven’t. Probably the most underrated ABA player ever. He was a 6’9 Center that played for the Indiana Pacers, his awards include: 7 time ABA All Star 3 time ABA champion 2 time ABA MVP 1 time ABA all star game MVP 4 time All ABA first team ABA Rookie of the Year
and his career averages: 18.4ppg/14.9rpg/1.8apg
Now tell me how someone like that could be forgotten? A 3 time champion and 2 time MVP and averaged 15 rebounds a game?? My awards based ranking places him as the 30th best player of all time (!!), right between Dirk Nowitzki and Paul Arizin.
2. Artis Gilmore
Artis Gilmore
Along with Julius Erving, probably the greatest ABA player of all time. And yet he wasn’t elected to the Hall of Fame until 2011. How is this possible? His awards: 11 time ABA/NBA All Star 3 time ABA champion 1 time ABA Finals MVP 1 time ABA MVP 1 time ABA all star game MVP 5 time All ABA first team ABA Rookie of the Year
and averaged.. 18.8ppg/12.3rpg/2.4bpg
My awards based ranking places him as the 36th best player of all time (!!), right between Isiah Thomas and Dwight Howard. This guy should be a top 10 center of all time, but its always left out of conversations.
3. George McGinnis
George McGinnis
He was one of the most important players in the ABA along with Julius Erving, yet he isn’t even in the Hall of Fame yet! How is that possible? His awards:
6 time ABA/NBA All Star 2 time ABA champion 1 time ABA MVP 3 time All ABA first team
and averaged.. 20.2ppg/11.0rpg/3.7apg
How can a former MVP and 2 time champion who averaged 20/11 be forgotten?? My awards based ranking places him as the 39th best player of all time, right between John Stockton and Willis Reed.
4. Rick Barry
Rick Barry
Rick Barry does get acknowledge as one of the great small forwards, but I think not enough as he deserves. Look at his awards and stats:
12 time ABA/NBA All Star 2 time ABA/NBA champion 1 time NBA Finals MVP 9 time All ABA/NBA First Team NBA All Star game MVP NBA Rookie of the Year 1 time NBA scoring champion
and averaged.. 24.8ppg/6.7rpg/4.9apg
Rick Barry doesn’t get the credit he deserves. His stats and awards using my ranking makes him the 19th best player of all time, right between Karl Malone and Elgin Baylor. He has better stats than Kobe Bryant. He averaged 27 points a game in the playoffs. He lead the ABA AND NBA in scoring. He lead the Golden State Warriors to their only championship in 1975 almost by himself. He is one of the greatest players of all time, period, yet gets left off the all time nba fantasy draft. He is hardly ever mentioned by modern players. Most players place Scottie Pippen over him. Why??
5. Connie Hawkins
Connie Hawkins
Connie Hawkins was basically another Julius Erving, except not remembered as much. Why not? He started kind of late in the NBA, due to the NBA banning him for a scandal that he wasn’t a part of, but his awards include:
5 time ABA/NBA All Star 1 time ABA Finals MVP 1 time ABA MVP 3 time All ABA/NBA First Team
and averaged.. 18.7ppg/8.8rpg/4.1apg
My awards based ranking places him as the 41th best player of all time, right between Willis Reed and Chris Paul. Again, no one talks about him or mentions him but the dude averaged 25/12 in the playoffs.
Other forgotten former ABA players include
6. Spencer Haywood, a former ABA MVP, averaged 20/10 yet isn’t in the hall of fame.
7. Roger Brown, an all but forgotten ABA star that averaged 17/6/4 for his career.
8. Billy Cunningham isn’t mentioned that much either, even though he is a former ABA MVP, 21/10 player, and one of the top 50 greatest of all time.
9. David Thompson, a former ABA player who averaged 22/3/4, scored 73 points in a game before, and one of the greatest dunkers of all time, is often forgotten.
10. Dan Issel, a 22/9 ABA player who helped Gilmore win his championship but isn’t mentioned amongst the great power forwards.